I agree with your opinion but would like to offer a couple of more points...I have both acoustic and TD-7 Roland drums. Electronic drums require a good sound system, perferrably with a sub woofer to give the bass drum good 'kick'. It's even more important if you are playing rock type music. I have a 100 watt peavey amp and was very disappointed with the sound. I bought a PA system and was still disappointed with the sound. I would probably be okay with it if I would drop the bucks for a sub but don't think I will. The other problem I have with electrics is the response of the heads. The newer Vdrum type systems are better but they still don't have the feel of accoustic. If you are like me and play both, it takes a while to get used to the different 'bounce' to control it properly. Oh well, just thought I would say something, even though your message is a couple of months old. It's my first time to read this group.
Have fun!
Well said.
Comparing electric to acoustic drums, is sort of like comparing acoustic to electric guitars. They each have their benefits and weaknesses depending on the situation.
In my opinion, the advantages of an electronic set are:
?The ability to change sounds from song to song ?Quiet practice ?Sounds don't change based on the weather/humidity ?Heads don't wear out as quick
The advantages of an acoustic set are:
?More immediate response ?Greater nuance in the sounds (especially in cymbals) ?No need to lug a PA to gigs ?More personal connection to the instrument
IMHO, not all music sounds good with electronic drums. You need to decide what kind of music most interests you as a player. Then decide if electronic drums are appropriate. You wouldn't want to play heavy metal with an acoustic guitar, or folk with a Les Paul and a Marshall Stack!
Sincerely, Jonathan Appell
Jonathan Appell Productions, Inc. Web Site:
http://www.erols.com/appellproductions
